• About us
    • Who we are
    • Mission
  • Contacts
  • English
    • Português (Portuguese (Portugal))
    • Español (Spanish)
    • Français (French)
  • Login
  • Register
Investorpolis
Advertisement
  • Home
  • Investing Series Guide
    • All
    • I. Goal Based Investing
    • II. Compounding & Inflation
    • III. Assets Risks & Returns
    • IV. Efficient Diversification
    • IX. Sustainable Investing and ESG
    • V. The Investor
    • VI. Assets and Investments
    • VII. Index Funds
    • VIII. Successful Investing
    • XI. Other Topics
    Simple Portfolio Series (DIY) Part 2: The Traditional Portfolio 60/40, what it is, for whom, and its performance

    Simple Portfolio Series (DIY) Part 2: The Traditional Portfolio 60/40, what it is, for whom, and its performance

    Simple or Lazy Portfolio Series (DIY): Part 1 – Overview

    Simple or Lazy Portfolio Series (DIY): Part 1 – Overview

    Choosing Mutual Funds Series: Part 5 – Funds availability and currency of investment

    Choosing Mutual Funds Series: Part 5 – Funds availability and currency of investment

    Maximize time invested in the stock market instead of market timing: Part 2. Impossibilities and losses (cont.)

    Maximize time invested in the stock market instead of market timing: Part 2. Impossibilities and losses (cont.)

    Maximizing time invested in the stock market instead of market timing: Part 1 – Biases and losses

    Maximizing time invested in the stock market instead of market timing: Part 1 – Biases and losses

    ESG Investing Series: Part 9 – Developments and models of corporate governance regulation in the world

    ESG Investing Series: Part 9 – Developments and models of corporate governance regulation in the world

    Trending Tags

      • I. Goal Based Investing
      • II. Compounding & Inflation
      • III. Assets Risks & Returns
      • IV. Efficient Diversification
      • V. The Investor
      • VI. Assets and Investments
      • VIII. Successful Investing
      • IX. Sustainable Investing and ESG
      • X. Kits and Tips
      • XI. Other Topics
    • Wealth and Investing
      • All
      • Investing
      • Wealth
      How Women invest: Part 2 – The results are equivalent to those of men, but with significant differences in investment management

      How Women invest: Part 2 – The results are equivalent to those of men, but with significant differences in investment management

      Outlook 2023: Part 5 – 2023 will be a transitional year with two halves

      Outlook 2023: Part 5 – 2023 will be a transitional year with two halves

      Outlook 2023: Part 4 – In changing economic cycle, policies, and market sentiment, valuation matters become more than ever

      Outlook 2023: Part 4 – In changing economic cycle, policies, and market sentiment, valuation matters become more than ever

      Outlook 2023: Part 3 – 2022 was bad for investments, but was not the same for everything

      Outlook 2023: Part 3 – 2022 was bad for investments, but was not the same for everything

      Outlook 2023: Part 2 – Investment losses in 2022 cost so much that sometimes we forget about previous gains

      Outlook 2023: Part 2 – Investment losses in 2022 cost so much that sometimes we forget about previous gains

      Outlook 2023: Part 1 – 2022 was a bad year for investments, but we can’t lose the medium and long-term perspective

      Outlook 2023: Part 1 – 2022 was a bad year for investments, but we can’t lose the medium and long-term perspective

      Trending Tags

        • Investing
        • Wealth
      • Retirement & Savings
        • All
        • Retirement
        • Savings
        Retirement Series: How much money do we need to live through retirement?

        Retirement Series: How much money do we need to live through retirement?

        Retirement Series: Part 1 – Overview – A backwards view

        Retirement Series: Part 1 – Overview – A backwards view

        How many years do our public or social pensions last?

        What is the replacement rate of retirement pensions?

        How many years will we live in retirement?

        Planning for a good financial life in retirement

        Trending Tags

          • Retirement
          • Savings
        • Tools
          • All
          • Calculators
          • Publications
          • Sites and apps
          Morningstar Rating for Funds

          Morningstar Rating for Funds

          Morningstar’s European Active/Passive Barometer

          Morningstar’s European Active/Passive Barometer

          Morningstar’s U.S. Active vs. Passive Barometer

          Morningstar’s U.S. Active vs. Passive Barometer

          The Power of Dividends: Past, Present, and Future, Hartford Funds, 2021

          The Power of Dividends: Past, Present, and Future, Hartford Funds, 2021

          OECD Corporate Governance Factbook 2021

          OECD Corporate Governance Factbook 2021

          G20/OECD Principles of Corporate Governance, 2015

          G20/OECD Principles of Corporate Governance, 2015

          Trending Tags

          • calculators
          • Calculators
          • Publications
          • Sites and apps
        • More
          • All
          • Best of
          Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Dividend Stocks for Investors Outside the U.S.

          Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Dividend Stocks for Investors Outside the U.S.

          Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Dividend Stocks for U.S. Investors

          Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Dividend Stocks for U.S. Investors

          Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Investment Grade Bonds, Indexed, for Eurozone Investors

          Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Investment Grade Bonds, Indexed, for Eurozone Investors

          Best Of Mutual Funds Series: US Bonds, Indexed, for US Investors

          Best Of Mutual Funds Series: US Bonds, Indexed, for US Investors

          Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Passive, US Large Stocks, for Non-US Investors

          Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Passive, US Large Stocks, for Non-US Investors

          Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Passive Large US Stocks for US Investors

          Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Passive Large US Stocks for US Investors

          Trending Tags

            • Best of
            • Reviews
            • Snapshots
            • Others
          No Result
          View All Result
          • Home
          • Investing Series Guide
            • All
            • I. Goal Based Investing
            • II. Compounding & Inflation
            • III. Assets Risks & Returns
            • IV. Efficient Diversification
            • IX. Sustainable Investing and ESG
            • V. The Investor
            • VI. Assets and Investments
            • VII. Index Funds
            • VIII. Successful Investing
            • XI. Other Topics
            Simple Portfolio Series (DIY) Part 2: The Traditional Portfolio 60/40, what it is, for whom, and its performance

            Simple Portfolio Series (DIY) Part 2: The Traditional Portfolio 60/40, what it is, for whom, and its performance

            Simple or Lazy Portfolio Series (DIY): Part 1 – Overview

            Simple or Lazy Portfolio Series (DIY): Part 1 – Overview

            Choosing Mutual Funds Series: Part 5 – Funds availability and currency of investment

            Choosing Mutual Funds Series: Part 5 – Funds availability and currency of investment

            Maximize time invested in the stock market instead of market timing: Part 2. Impossibilities and losses (cont.)

            Maximize time invested in the stock market instead of market timing: Part 2. Impossibilities and losses (cont.)

            Maximizing time invested in the stock market instead of market timing: Part 1 – Biases and losses

            Maximizing time invested in the stock market instead of market timing: Part 1 – Biases and losses

            ESG Investing Series: Part 9 – Developments and models of corporate governance regulation in the world

            ESG Investing Series: Part 9 – Developments and models of corporate governance regulation in the world

            Trending Tags

              • I. Goal Based Investing
              • II. Compounding & Inflation
              • III. Assets Risks & Returns
              • IV. Efficient Diversification
              • V. The Investor
              • VI. Assets and Investments
              • VIII. Successful Investing
              • IX. Sustainable Investing and ESG
              • X. Kits and Tips
              • XI. Other Topics
            • Wealth and Investing
              • All
              • Investing
              • Wealth
              How Women invest: Part 2 – The results are equivalent to those of men, but with significant differences in investment management

              How Women invest: Part 2 – The results are equivalent to those of men, but with significant differences in investment management

              Outlook 2023: Part 5 – 2023 will be a transitional year with two halves

              Outlook 2023: Part 5 – 2023 will be a transitional year with two halves

              Outlook 2023: Part 4 – In changing economic cycle, policies, and market sentiment, valuation matters become more than ever

              Outlook 2023: Part 4 – In changing economic cycle, policies, and market sentiment, valuation matters become more than ever

              Outlook 2023: Part 3 – 2022 was bad for investments, but was not the same for everything

              Outlook 2023: Part 3 – 2022 was bad for investments, but was not the same for everything

              Outlook 2023: Part 2 – Investment losses in 2022 cost so much that sometimes we forget about previous gains

              Outlook 2023: Part 2 – Investment losses in 2022 cost so much that sometimes we forget about previous gains

              Outlook 2023: Part 1 – 2022 was a bad year for investments, but we can’t lose the medium and long-term perspective

              Outlook 2023: Part 1 – 2022 was a bad year for investments, but we can’t lose the medium and long-term perspective

              Trending Tags

                • Investing
                • Wealth
              • Retirement & Savings
                • All
                • Retirement
                • Savings
                Retirement Series: How much money do we need to live through retirement?

                Retirement Series: How much money do we need to live through retirement?

                Retirement Series: Part 1 – Overview – A backwards view

                Retirement Series: Part 1 – Overview – A backwards view

                How many years do our public or social pensions last?

                What is the replacement rate of retirement pensions?

                How many years will we live in retirement?

                Planning for a good financial life in retirement

                Trending Tags

                  • Retirement
                  • Savings
                • Tools
                  • All
                  • Calculators
                  • Publications
                  • Sites and apps
                  Morningstar Rating for Funds

                  Morningstar Rating for Funds

                  Morningstar’s European Active/Passive Barometer

                  Morningstar’s European Active/Passive Barometer

                  Morningstar’s U.S. Active vs. Passive Barometer

                  Morningstar’s U.S. Active vs. Passive Barometer

                  The Power of Dividends: Past, Present, and Future, Hartford Funds, 2021

                  The Power of Dividends: Past, Present, and Future, Hartford Funds, 2021

                  OECD Corporate Governance Factbook 2021

                  OECD Corporate Governance Factbook 2021

                  G20/OECD Principles of Corporate Governance, 2015

                  G20/OECD Principles of Corporate Governance, 2015

                  Trending Tags

                  • calculators
                  • Calculators
                  • Publications
                  • Sites and apps
                • More
                  • All
                  • Best of
                  Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Dividend Stocks for Investors Outside the U.S.

                  Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Dividend Stocks for Investors Outside the U.S.

                  Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Dividend Stocks for U.S. Investors

                  Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Dividend Stocks for U.S. Investors

                  Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Investment Grade Bonds, Indexed, for Eurozone Investors

                  Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Investment Grade Bonds, Indexed, for Eurozone Investors

                  Best Of Mutual Funds Series: US Bonds, Indexed, for US Investors

                  Best Of Mutual Funds Series: US Bonds, Indexed, for US Investors

                  Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Passive, US Large Stocks, for Non-US Investors

                  Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Passive, US Large Stocks, for Non-US Investors

                  Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Passive Large US Stocks for US Investors

                  Best Of Mutual Funds Series: Passive Large US Stocks for US Investors

                  Trending Tags

                    • Best of
                    • Reviews
                    • Snapshots
                    • Others
                  No Result
                  View All Result
                  Investorpolis
                  No Result
                  View All Result
                  Home Investing Series Guide

                  Investor biases: Narrow Framing

                  2 de July, 2020
                  in Investing Series Guide, V. The Investor
                  Reading Time: 6 mins read
                  0 0
                  0
                  Enviesamentos do investidor: Enquadramento Estreito
                  Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

                  What is Narrow Framing?

                  The bias of the narrow framing in investing

                  How can we protect ourselves from this bias?

                  What is Narrow Framing?

                  Narrow framework is to make decisions without considering all the implications.

                  The narrow framing bias comes when we focus on the details rather than looking at the overall picture. This framing can undermine our decision-making capabilities because it prevents us from seeing our choices within their context.

                  The framing effect is a cognitive bias in which people decide on options based on whether they are presented with positive or negative connotations, for example, as a loss or as a gain.

                  People tend to avoid risks when they are presented with a positive picture but look for risks when they are presented with a negative picture. Gain and loss are defined in the scenario as descriptions of outcomes (e.g., lost or saved lives, patients with treated and untreated diseases, etc.).

                  The prospect theory, developed by Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman in 1979, shows that a loss is more significant than an equivalent gain, that a certain gain (certainty effect and pseudo-certainty effect) is favoured over a probabilistic gain, and that a probabilistic loss is preferable to a definitive loss. One of the dangers of framing effects is that people are often given options within the context of only one of the two frames.

                  In 1981, those academics explored how different phrases affected participants’ responses to a choice of a hypothetical life-and-death situation.

                  Participants were asked to choose between two treatments for 600 people affected by a deadly disease. Treatment A was predicted to result in 400 deaths, while treatment B was 33% likely to die, but a 66% chance of all dying. This choice was presented to the participants with a positive framework, that is, how many people would live, or with a negative framework, i.e., how many people would die.

                  FramingTreatmentA Treatment B
                  Positive“200 lives are saved ““A 33% probability of saving all 600 people, and 66% of not saving.”
                  Negative“400 people die”“A 33% probability that no one will die, and 66% where all 600 people will die.”

                  Treatment A was chosen by 72% of the participants when it was presented with a positive framework (“200 lives are saved”), falling to 22% when the same choice was presented with a negative framework (“400 people die”).

                  The bias of the narrow framing in investing

                  The effect of the narrow framing has been consistently proven to be one of the strongest biases in decision-making.

                  As a result of the framing effect, investors tend to react to investment options inappropriately. Investors accept or reject a proposal depending on how it is framed. In cases where the result is the same, they will agree to the proposals presented as risky gains and reject those portrayed as risky losses.

                  This makes investment decisions inaccurate and influenced by bias.

                  The framing effect can also be used to mislead investors into certain schemes, investment vehicles and companies.

                  One of the most well-known investment schemes is the Ponzi scheme whereby a respectable manager promises to pay above normal returns to investors that are paid by as ever-growing inflow of money by new investors:

                  When there is not enough new money coming in to pay the promised returns, the system collapses and investors lose all their money.

                  Companies frame the information in such a way that their positives are more prominent than usual, as well as the negative points of competitors. This will cause investors to make incorrect decisions, leading to huge financial losses.

                  When a positive picture is presented to investors, they are more likely to avoid risks. And when the negative picture is presented, investors are more likely to look for risks. It is also important to note that the framing effect increases with age, so older investors are more affected than younger ones.

                  The Enron story is a highly known case-study by academia and financial practitioners:

                  During the run-up to the technology bubble in the late 1990s, Enron rode the wave and promised to transform the energy business, and even the internet, with bandwidth trading.

                  The market anointed Enron as a transformative leader. At its peak in 2001, Enron’s stock price reached more than $90 per share, and its market capitalization topped $66 billion.

                  The company was part of the so-called New Economy, which was light on assets and fast moving. And Enron fulfilled this perception until the early part of 2001. Then, Enron lost its reputation in a wave of scandals, culminating in the company’s spectacular collapse.

                  A more recent example is the Wirecard story, a German based payments group that became one of the hottest stocks in Europe while battling persistent allegations of fraud and ended up filing for insolvency.

                  Wirecard was founded in 1999 in Munich, was listed in 2005 in Frankfurt, entered the banking business and started in a buying spree of companies all over the world, in Europe, North America and Asia.

                  From 2008 onwards there were several accusations of fraudulent activities constantly rebuffed by the company with the support of its lawyers and auditors.

                  In August 2018, Wirecard shares hit a peak of €191, valuing it at more than €24bn. The group claimed it had 5,000 employees, who processed payments for about 250,000 merchants, issued credit and prepaid cards and provided technology for contactless smartphone payments.

                  At the end June 2020, Wirecard acknowledged for the first time the potential scale of a multiyear accounting fraud, warning that the €1.9bn of cash probably does “not exist”. Wirecard says it will file for insolvency.

                  One consequence of the narrow framing is that we select securities rather than choosing to invest in collective funds or investment products that provide us with a more appropriate diversification:

                  Most US households still prefer to invest directly in stocks than in equity funds, to the detriment of diversification, cost savings and professional allocation and management. However, the trend of the last four decades is clearly an increase in investments via funds.

                  How can we protect ourselves from this bias?

                  One of the things we can do as an investor is always challenge the framing. We can reformulate the information we receive and see the impact, if any, that it has on our conclusion. The important thing is to try to activate the logical and reflexive approach to decision making and avoid impulsive and reflective decisions.

                  For example, any media news, company press release, or analyst investment report can contain many opinions and biases.

                  We must try to remove any editorial/critical comments and look at only the key numbers and underlying assumptions that drive the assessment. Then come to our own conclusions, rather than being influenced by how information is presented to us.

                  Regarding financial markets and investments, as well as in much aspects in life, not everything is as good as it seems, not as bad as one thinks!

                  https://thedecisionlab.com/biases/framing-effect/

                  https://www.behavioraleconomics.com/resources/mini-encyclopedia-of-be/framing-effect/

                  Previous Post

                  Investor biases: Herding or herd instinct

                  Next Post

                  Financial Markets Outlook 3Q20: A Bridge Too Far?

                  Investadmin

                  Investadmin

                  Related Posts

                  Simple Portfolio Series (DIY) Part 2: The Traditional Portfolio 60/40, what it is, for whom, and its performance
                  Investing Series Guide

                  Simple Portfolio Series (DIY) Part 2: The Traditional Portfolio 60/40, what it is, for whom, and its performance

                  28 de January, 2023
                  Simple or Lazy Portfolio Series (DIY): Part 1 – Overview
                  Investing Series Guide

                  Simple or Lazy Portfolio Series (DIY): Part 1 – Overview

                  28 de January, 2023
                  Choosing Mutual Funds Series: Part 5 – Funds availability and currency of investment
                  Investing Series Guide

                  Choosing Mutual Funds Series: Part 5 – Funds availability and currency of investment

                  24 de January, 2023
                  Maximize time invested in the stock market instead of market timing: Part 2. Impossibilities and losses (cont.)
                  Investing Series Guide

                  Maximize time invested in the stock market instead of market timing: Part 2. Impossibilities and losses (cont.)

                  21 de November, 2022
                  Maximizing time invested in the stock market instead of market timing: Part 1 – Biases and losses
                  Investing Series Guide

                  Maximizing time invested in the stock market instead of market timing: Part 1 – Biases and losses

                  21 de November, 2022
                  ESG Investing Series: Part 9 – Developments and models of corporate governance regulation in the world
                  Investing Series Guide

                  ESG Investing Series: Part 9 – Developments and models of corporate governance regulation in the world

                  15 de August, 2022
                  Next Post
                  Desempenho e Perspetivas dos Mercados Financeiros 3T20: Uma ponte longe demais?

                  Financial Markets Outlook 3Q20: A Bridge Too Far?

                  Leave a Reply

                  Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

                  Trending

                  How Women invest: Part 2 – The results are equivalent to those of men, but with significant differences in investment management

                  How Women invest: Part 2 – The results are equivalent to those of men, but with significant differences in investment management

                  2 de March, 2023
                  Outlook 2023: Part 5 – 2023 will be a transitional year with two halves

                  Outlook 2023: Part 5 – 2023 will be a transitional year with two halves

                  17 de February, 2023
                  Outlook 2023: Part 4 – In changing economic cycle, policies, and market sentiment, valuation matters become more than ever

                  Outlook 2023: Part 4 – In changing economic cycle, policies, and market sentiment, valuation matters become more than ever

                  17 de February, 2023
                  Outlook 2023: Part 3 – 2022 was bad for investments, but was not the same for everything

                  Outlook 2023: Part 3 – 2022 was bad for investments, but was not the same for everything

                  16 de February, 2023
                  Investorpolis

                  We developed this blog because we believe that only a small learning effort is needed to make a big change in the decisions and results of our investments and financial assets.

                  Main categories

                  • Investing Series Guide
                  • Wealth and Investing
                  • Retirement & Savings
                  • Tools
                  • More

                  Newsletter

                  Sign to our mailing list to receive updates direct to your inbox!

                  *We don’t spam

                  • Privacy Policy
                  • Cookie Policy
                  • Contacts

                  © 2021 - Investorpolis / Powered by Delta Soluções

                  • pt-pt Português
                  • fr Français
                  • es Español
                  • en English
                  • Home
                  • Investing Series Guide
                    • I. Goal Based Investing
                    • II. Compounding & Inflation
                    • III. Assets Risks & Returns
                    • IV. Efficient Diversification
                    • IX. Sustainable Investing and ESG
                    • V. The Investor
                    • VI. Assets and Investments
                    • VII. Index Funds
                    • VIII. Successful Investing
                    • X. Kits and Tips
                    • XI. Other Topics
                  • Retirement & Savings
                    • Retirement
                    • Savings
                  • Wealth and Investing
                    • Investing
                    • Wealth
                  • Tools
                    • Calculators
                    • Publications
                    • Sites and apps
                  • More
                    • Best of
                    • Reviews
                    • Snapshots
                    • Others
                  • About us
                    • Who we are
                    • Mission
                  • Login
                  • Sign Up
                  • Cart

                  © 2021 - Investorpolis / Powered by Delta Soluções

                  Welcome Back!

                  Login to your account below

                  Forgotten Password? Sign Up

                  Create New Account!

                  Fill the forms bellow to register

                  All fields are required. Log In

                  Retrieve your password

                  Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

                  Log In
                  We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent.
                  Cookie configurationCookie PolicyAcceptReject
                  Manage consent

                  Privacy Overview

                  This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
                  Advertisement
                  Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
                  Analytics
                  Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
                  Functional
                  Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
                  Necessary
                  Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously.
                  Others
                  Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
                  Performance
                  Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
                  SAVE & ACCEPT

                  Add New Playlist

                  Are you sure want to unlock this post?
                  Unlock left : 0
                  Are you sure want to cancel subscription?